Bitcoin has lost half its value in 13 months. Business school research suggests the adviser most likely to have got you into it is your best friend.
Bitcoin fell below $64,000 on Saturday, its lowest level in three months. That’s roughly half its record of $126,080, set in October 2025, and it means only a fortunate few haven’t lost money. When it dropped below $64,000, $691 million of crypto positions were forcibly closed within one hour, and $671 million of those were bets that prices would rise. Bitcoin is now down more than 20% since late October and is on course for a sixth weekly loss in a row.
Most crash coverage looks at Federal Reserve policy, ETF outflows and leverage. This piece looks at the dinner table, and who encouraged you to buy Bitcoin. Crypto spreads from friend to friend more than almost any other investment, and the research on how that works explains a lot about why so many people bought near the top.
Why crypto spreads from friend to friend
In a 2022 study by the FINRA Investor Education Foundation and NORC at the University of Chicago, 31% of new crypto investors said a friend’s suggestion was their main reason for buying. For new investors in stocks and bonds, the figure was 8%. 48% of crypto investors also said they got most of their information from friends, family or colleagues, against 35% of stock investors.
The study’s authors concluded that crypto investing has “a social element” that you don’t see in equities or bonds. Business school researchers have been studying that social element for years, and their findings fall into four groups.
Investors share their gains and hide their losses
Markku Kaustia of Aalto University School of Business in Helsinki and Samuli Knüpfer now at London Business School studied first-time stock buyers in Finland. They found that strong recent returns among a person’s local peers made that person much more likely to start buying shares. Poor returns had no matching effect: they didn’t make people any less likely to start investing.
The authors’ explanation is very human. People don’t talk about decisions that turned out badly. Your neighbour mentions the shares that doubled and skips the ones that halved. You get half the story, and it’s the better half.
Bing Han of the University of Toronto’s Rotman School, David Hirshleifer at USC Marshall, and Johan Walden of Berkeley Haas turned this into a theory of how investment ideas spread. They call it “self-enhancing transmission bias”. Investors are keener to report their successes, so the stories that circulate are skewed upwards. Their model helps explain why investors who socialise more are drawn to volatile, lottery-style bets. The paper opens with a line from Robert Shiller: “Investing in speculative assets is a social activity.”
Bitcoin is about as volatile and lottery-like as mainstream assets get. Every investor who bought at $10,000 in 2020 and sold at $100,000 had a great story to tell. The investor who bought at $120,000 last October has been much quieter.
Does online optimism predict a Bitcoin crash?
The newest research goes further. Bing Han has a 2026 working paper published by the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas, written with Haoyang Liu of the Dallas Fed and Pengfei Sui of the Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shenzhen. They studied 666,006 posts by 44,356 users on Bitcointalk, one of crypto’s oldest forums, between 2012 and 2022, and linked 2,550 of those users to their actual trading records.
They found that people drift towards the mood of the conversation around them, and that the mood itself doesn’t predict where Bitcoin goes next. Inexperienced users shifted their views more than experienced ones. Bulls also reacted strongly to bullish posts and barely at all to bearish ones, which the authors read as confirmation bias. The mood also moved money. After upbeat conversations, investors were more likely to buy the next day.
The striking result is what happens next. When positive sentiment was spreading through the network, the chance of a crash in the following three days rose by 4.7 percentage points. Over two weeks it rose by 14.9 points. The data stops in 2022, so it can’t tell us what happened this autumn. The pattern is still clear: the moment everyone around you is most excited is the moment to be most careful.
Most finfluencers give bad investment advice
For many younger investors, the “friend” is someone they’ve never met. Norman Schürhoff of the University of Lausanne and the Swiss Finance Institute, working with Ali Kakhbod and Dmitry Livdan of Berkeley Haas and Seyed Kazempour, studied financial influencers. They analysed 72 million posts from more than 29,000 finfluencers on StockTwits, a social network for investors. Their data covers stock tips rather than crypto, but the lesson carries over.
Only 28% of finfluencers gave advice that beat the market, by an average of 2.6% a month. 56% were “antiskilled”: following them lost you 2.3% a month against the market. The unskilled and antiskilled had more followers and more influence on retail trading than the skilled ones. What drove popularity was frequent, entertaining posting, even when it was too optimistic and came near price peaks. The advice was so reliably wrong that doing the opposite earned 1.2% a month.
Keeping up with the crypto Joneses
The last strand explains why people act on these stories even when they suspect they’re incomplete. Sumit Agarwal of NUS Business School in Singapore, with Vyacheslav Mikhed of the Philadelphia Fed and Barry Scholnick of the University of Alberta, studied what happens to people who live next door to lottery winners in Canada. Each extra C$1,000 of prize money led to a 2.4% rise in bankruptcies among the winner’s close neighbours. Those neighbours spent more on visible goods, borrowed more and put more money into speculative investments.
Crypto gains are the closest thing most of us see to a neighbour’s lottery win, and they’re often just as visible. Research led by Scott Baker of Northwestern Kellogg found that for every household that withdrew $5,000 from a crypto exchange, one in 20 bought a home for the first time. When a friend moves into a new flat paid for with Bitcoin, the case for buying makes itself.
How should you judge crypto tips from friends?
None of this means friends give worse advice than banks. It means they give advice that has passed through a filter, and the research tells us which way it bends. A few practical lessons follow.
Ask about the losses. If a friend recommends an investment, ask about their worst trade. Kaustia’s work suggests you probably haven’t heard about it, and their answer will tell you whether you’re hearing a full record or a highlights reel.
Treat collective excitement as a warning sign. The Bitcointalk study found that optimism spreading through a network came before crashes. The antiskilled finfluencers were most bullish near the peaks. When everyone in your group chat agrees, that’s information, but it may be the opposite of what they think it is.
Watch who’s doing the convincing. Inexperienced investors are the ones whose views move most with the crowd. They’re also the people most likely to have bought late.
And if you’re the friend who did the talking, there’s an obvious next step. The research shows how gains get passed on and losses go unmentioned. You can fix that in one message. Tell your friends you’ve lost half your money too. Self-enhancing transmission bias works both ways, and admitting your losses is the cheapest correction any market will offer this year.
Crypto is likely to recover at some point, as it has after every previous crash. When it does, someone at a dinner party will tell you about the coin that went up 400%. Ask about the one that went to zero. If they can’t remember it, send them this article. And if you can’t remember who talked you into Bitcoin in the first place, it may have been you.
Interested in this topic? You might also like…
