The Chinese President, Xi Jinping stood up at the APEC summit in Shenzhen and made the case for open trade, regional integration and investment across the Asia-Pacific. Donald Trump, seated nearby, lowered his head, clasped his hands and appeared to close his eyes for about 10 seconds.
Critics including Gavin Newsom’s press office and George Conway said the president had dozed off. White House communications director Steven Cheung called it “Fake News!” and said Trump was looking at papers in front of him. “You can clearly see his eyes move back and forth,” he added.
Trump then flew home on a nearly 15-hour nonstop Air Force One flight, which commemorative cards handed to the press called the longest in the plane’s history. Fox News correspondent Aishah Hasnie said he told her: “I don’t sleep until I get back to the White House.”
There’s a back catalogue. Indy100 has counted at least 29 occasions in his second term when Trump appeared to fall asleep on camera. Asked in February about a clip from a December cabinet meeting, he was refreshingly honest about meetings: “Look, it got pretty boring. I didn’t sleep. I just closed them because I wanted to get the hell outta here.”
Anyone who has sat through a 3pm meeting in a warm room, watching someone else’s slides, knows the feeling. But what happens to leaders who don’t sleep? And does a planned nap beat a stolen one?
Does lack of sleep make leaders less effective?
“I don’t sleep” has a long history as a leadership credential. Margaret Thatcher was famous for getting by on 4 hours a night. Elon Musk has talked about sleeping on the factory floor at Tesla.
The research is unkind to the idea. Christopher Barnes at the University of Washington’s Foster School of Business has made sleep the centre of his work in management. In one study he asked 88 business students to write and deliver a commencement speech on camera, with half of them sleep-deprived the night before. Judges who didn’t know who had slept rated the tired speakers as less charismatic.
A second experiment found the problem runs both ways. Sleep-deprived followers were harder to inspire, whoever was at the lectern.
Other studies by Barnes and his colleagues found that leaders who slept badly were more hostile to their staff and less sincere in what they said. Tired leaders are also more likely to behave unethically, because fatigue weakens self-control at the moment temptation turns up. “Leaders and their teams are typically going to be better served by a good night of sleep than by working so much that they crowd out sleep,” he told HuffPost.
Barnes also points to research showing that people read fatigue in a face: drooping eyelids, the corners of the mouth, pale skin. A head of state on a summit camera has nowhere to hide them.
Inemuri, and why senior staff in Japan can sleep at work
Japan has a word for what happened in Shenzhen. Inemuri is often translated as “sleeping on duty”, though Brigitte Steger, who studies Japanese society at the University of Cambridge, says “sleeping while present” is closer. It has been practised for at least 1,000 years, on trains, in lectures and at office desks.
Steger’s research shows it comes with rules. Inemuri is most common among senior white-collar employees, while junior staff are expected to stay awake all day and look energetic. “The higher up the social ladder you are, the more you can sleep,” she told The Guardian. Posture matters, and women are more likely to be criticised for sleeping in a position judged unbecoming.
The main condition is that the sleeper stays part of the meeting. They have to be able to return to the conversation the moment they’re needed. Being seen to doze can even signal diligence, proof that you’ve worked yourself to exhaustion. Steger has also studied politicians dozing in Japan’s parliament, where it’s a familiar sight.
By those rules, an 80-year-old head of state nodding through a counterpart’s speech after a week of travel is within etiquette. The test comes when it’s his turn to speak.
Do naps at work increase productivity?
If people are going to close their eyes at work, the evidence says they should do it on purpose.
Mattie Toma at Warwick Business School worked with Pedro Bessone and Frank Schilbach of MIT, Heather Schofield of the University of Pennsylvania and Gautam Rao of Harvard on one of the few field studies of sleep and real work. About 450 low-income adults in Chennai, India, did data-entry work in an office for 3 weeks while actigraphs tracked their sleep at home. They spent roughly 8 hours in bed but slept only about 5 and a half.
The team tried 2 fixes. Helping people sleep longer at night added 27 minutes a night and made no difference to their productivity, cognition or wellbeing. A 30-minute afternoon nap in a quiet room did. The nappers were 2.3% more productive across the day, with better cognition and psychological wellbeing. The researchers estimate the effect was similar to a 50% pay rise. The naps were timed for the mid-afternoon dip in energy that most office workers will recognise.
At Corvinus University of Budapest, Amitabh Anand, who is also a professor at Excelia Business School in France, reviewed the published research with Rita Tóth, Jessica Doll of Appalachian State University and Sanjay Kumar Singh of the University of Dundee School of Business. Their 2024 paper in the European Management Journal links short naps during the working day to fewer errors, lower absenteeism and more frequent promotions. One US report they cite found that employees allowed to nap were 18% more likely to say they’d been promoted in the past year.
Length matters. Naps of about 20 minutes or less improve alertness and concentration. In one study a 15-minute nap lifted alertness within 30 minutes of waking, while a 45-minute nap took around 3 hours to show any benefit. Anand says a nap at work shouldn’t run past 30 minutes. A short nap, he says, “can significantly improve workers’ mood, memory, cognitive performance and creativity for the rest of the day.”
Managers nap at work more than their staff
The Corvinus review has a finding Steger would recognise. Of people who nap at work, 55% are managers, compared with 41% of those who don’t. Seniority buys sleep in Western offices too.
Policies vary by sector. About a quarter of technology workers said their managers allowed naps. Napping was banned for 62% of IT workers and 57% of people in finance and insurance. Google and Facebook have put sleep pods in their headquarters, and Toma notes that more than a quarter of Gen Z workers look for benefits such as nap pods and quiet rooms to help them cope with stress.
The cost of getting it wrong is large. A 2018 RAND analysis estimated that lost sleep costs countries up to 3% of GDP. Most employers still treat closed eyes at a desk as a disciplinary matter.
The best time to sleep on the job
The lesson from Shenzhen is mostly about timing. According to the research, a 20-minute nap before a long afternoon session is good management. A 10-second one during the keynote, with a camera on you and the leader of the world’s second-largest economy at the lectern, is a communications problem.
For leaders who like to say they don’t sleep, Barnes’s work suggests their staff notice the tiredness more than the stamina. The best time to close your eyes at a summit is the afternoon before it.
Interested in this topic? You might also like…
