Much like every other fast fashion brand, SHEIN proudly displays its sustainability policy, with a series of seemingly far-fetched promises for 2030 under its ‘evoluSHEIN’ strategy.
Yet reports in recent years indicate working conditions are appalling, with the company even being found to use child labour, and emissions exceed 16.7 million metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent per year, a higher output than four coal-fired power plants.
Economists are saying that backlash over its poor sustainability and labour practices, combined with ultra-low prices for its retail goods becoming harder to sustain, contributed to recent underperformance… despite strong sales, SHEIN’s long-anticipated trading debut on the Hong Kong stock exchange met a 10 percent slump.
Could it be that Gen-Z have stopped falling for fast fashion?
The new era of greenwashing
Gen-Z is renowned for caring about sustainability and being unafraid to admit it. In the Deloitte Gen Z and Millennial 2025 survey of 23,482 individuals, 65 percent of Gen-Z said they were even willing to pay more for environmentally sustainable products or services.?
They are also increasingly sceptical about fast fashion brands’ sustainability marketing, particularly vague terms such as ‘planet-friendly’ or ‘carbon neutral’ without the receipts to back them up, finds a recent study by Glasgow Caledonian University. Gen-Z wants specific, factual and measurable evidence, rather than broad marketing language.
So, while companies may use sustainability claims to appeal to the younger generation, the study argues that it might actually push them away.
The study finds that Gen-Z’s strong awareness of climate change, developed through universities, documentaries, news and social media, enables them to read through greenwashing tactics.
When a fast fashion company presents a small, sustainable initiative while continuing to produce large quantities in fast fashion, the researchers conclude Gen-Z customers will usually question the authenticity of the claims.
A good recent example of this is in-store repair services. Since 2022, popular high street brands like Uniqlo and Zara have started offering in-store clothing repair services in select stores.
In 2024, other well-known names hopped on the bandwagon, with department store Selfridges partnering with alterations platform Sojo to open a permanent in-store repair concession on Oxford Street. John Lewis, too, has teamed up with the Timpson Group to pilot in-store garment repair and alteration services.
But companies like Zara, which churn out approximately 11,000 new designs every year, are unlikely to fool a generation that can read between the lines.
These small actions, which are good PR but do very little to negate the company’s environmental impact, are being dubbed by some as a new form of greenwashing.
Why is fast fashion still popular?
Yet despite Gen-Z’s aversion to greenwashing, many still continue to shop at fast fashion sites: after all, it’s convenient, and fashions change so quickly. There’s pressure to keep up.
A 2024 study, led by researcher Dorit Zimand-Sheiner at Ariel University, looked into why Gen-Z customers still frequently buy from ultra-fast-fashion brands like SHEIN.
“Although Generation Z is known for its ethical and conscientious values, they are a major consumer segment of SHEIN fashion, a leading non-sustainable brand,” wrote the researchers.
The study looked at 607 Gen-Z SHEIN consumers and found that limited environmental knowledge about fashion and materialistic motivations meant that they would continue to buy from the retailer until they were exposed to information about their negative environmental practices.
“Following exposure to environmental information, negative attitudes toward SHEIN, along with perceived betrayal, were positively correlated with reduced purchase intention,” write the researchers.
A study from Sheffield Hallam University adds further nuances, revealing that gender also influences sustainable purchasing decisions.
Dr Marc Duffy, one of the academics who carried out the study, explains that the Gen-Z women who participated in the study said they would pay more for sustainable clothing, while the men showed a lack of concern and knowledge around sustainable fashion. Yet when it came to buying clothes, men’s buying habits were considerably more sustainable.
This was because they purchase fast fashion less frequently and source clothes from more sustainable retailers.
“However, this was not intentional – they preferred these brands as they were deemed trendy and cool,” says Dr Duffy.
To understand the reason for the gap between intention and actual purchasing decisions, the researchers identified six key barriers to sustainable clothes shopping: price, lack of knowledge, lack of choice, lack of aesthetic choice, scepticism over business transparency, and social desirability.
Is the data accurate?
With multiple studies citing access to knowledge as an important factor in Gen-Z purchasing decisions, it’s important to examine what the data is really telling us.
A study from the University of Cologne shares that companies’ carbon emissions have risen over 500 percent between 2014 and 2023. Yet, this sharp rise, the researchers find, is largely driven by companies disclosing more, not polluting more.
“Our study reveals that the total reported emissions increased by over 400% between 2020 and 2023 alone. However, when we examined the 15 individual categories that make up value-chain related emissions, such as business travel and product use, none of them showed a comparable upward trend,” says researcher Professor Maximilian A. Müller.
This shows why greater transparency can sometimes look like deteriorating performance. Nevertheless, from a consumer perspective, even when companies are transparent about the data, it can be difficult to understand the real-world implications.
For instance, when fast-fashion brands release detailed information, it’s difficult to understand how reported emissions reductions are achievable while they continue producing huge volumes of cheap clothing.
What can fast fashion companies do to survive?
With governments and international regulators introducing more stringent requirements around sustainability reporting, fast-fashion brands face mounting pressure to reveal more details about their ecological impact and labour conditions.
Access to information is shown to have a marked impact on Gen-Z’s purchasing decisions, and consumers in this age range are shown to be more adept at seeing through greenwashing tactics.
So, for companies looking to appeal to this market, only one choice remains: to embrace sustainability objectives wholeheartedly. Repair services instore offer a step in the right direction, but further progress down this avenue will be increasingly important to maintaining a favourable brand reputation.
It’s unlikely that SHEIN will close down anytime soon, of course. Gen Z hasn’t stopped buying fast fashion. But the evidence suggests that it is becoming much harder to sell the idea that fast fashion can be made sustainable with just a few small changes.
Chloë Lane
Chloë is a freelance journalist specialising in higher education and business topics. In addition to writing for BlueSky Thinking, her work has been published in QS Insights, QS Top Universities, and GMAC.
