Site icon Bluesky Thinking

Should Peter Thiel Be The Next Bond Villain?

Peter Thiel argues that “if you’re evil, you’re at least competent”, an idea that wouldn’t feel out of place among James Bond’s rogues’ gallery. (Credit: Landmark Media/Alamy).

By Adam Kelly-Moore

What is the opposite of good? It’s a question that sounds simple to answer, at least until Peter Thiel gets hold of it.

“The moral antonym is evil. The functional antonym is bad,” he said earlier this year on the MD MEETS podcast. He illustrated the distinction with a Ferrari and a Trabant. For Theil, a Ferrari can be described as ‘evil’ as it has poor fuel consumption but performs exceptionally well, whereas a Trabant is simply ‘bad’ because it is fundamentally a terrible car. He then arrives at the rather more troubling conclusion: “If you’re evil, you’re at least competent.”

Thiel was not arguing that evil is morally admirable. In fact, he was careful to say that he thought it was better to be good than evil. His actual point was stranger. In his theory, evil and bad are not synonyms. Evil describes something morally wrong; bad describes something that simply does not work. An evil person, by contrast, might at least be capable of getting something done.

“The distance between insanity and genius is measured only by success.”

Another great Thielian quote? In fact, it comes from Elliot Carver, the media mogul and Bond villain in Tomorrow Never Dies. How apt.

The line captures a tension at the heart of Thiel’s public persona – when does unconventional thinking become dangerous obsession, and when does it become visionary leadership? In business, the answer can depend heavily on the results.

Thiel’s argument on the concept of evil is provocative, contrarian and deliberately uncomfortable. This is a man who declared in 2009 that he no longer believed freedom and democracy were compatible, and who last year delivered a series of private lectures casting the Antichrist as a threat lurking behind efforts to regulate technology. In one lecture, he reportedly described climate activist Greta Thunberg and AI critic Eliezer Yudkowsky as “legionnaires of the Antichrist”.

His public persona seems almost engineered to provoke. It also raises a serious question about leadership. What if some of the characteristics we instinctively dislike in business leaders are precisely those that organisations sometimes reward?

There is already evidence that the answer is more complicated than it might seem.

The double-edged sword of CEO narcissism

Research into CEO personality has found that traits such as narcissism and overconfidence can have both positive and negative consequences for organisations.

A 2022 meta-analysis by Priscilla Kraft at WHU – Otto Beisheim School of Management examined 68 studies and found that CEO narcissism could contribute to firm performance by stimulating innovation. Narcissistic CEOs were more likely to pursue risky strategic actions, with innovation providing a route through which those behaviours could translate into better performance.

But the same research found that the benefits could be offset by harmful decisions. Narcissism was therefore not simply good or bad for companies: its consequences depended on what the CEO did with it.

That distinction is important. The research does not suggest that narcissists make better leaders. It suggests that some of the behaviours associated with narcissism, confidence, risk-taking, grandiosity and a willingness to pursue unconventional ideas, can be useful in circumstances where an organisation needs to do something different.

Overconfidence produces a similarly uncomfortable result.

Research by Marc Kowalzick and his former colleagues from the Mannheim Business School, the Technical University of Munich and the University of Hong Kong examined 240 turnaround cases involving S&P 1500 companies. It found that overconfidence could either help or hinder a company’s recovery depending on who possessed it.

An overconfident incumbent CEO who had already led a company into decline tended to make the situation worse. But an overconfident successor brought in during the decline could improve turnaround performance.

The explanation reveals that the same exaggerated self-belief that can cause an existing leader to ignore evidence of failure can give a new leader the confidence to formulate a bold recovery strategy, reassure stakeholders and challenge the status quo.

In other words, arrogance can look remarkably similar to conviction until the moment it goes wrong.

Why being liked isn’t the point

Research published in The Leadership Quarterly by Amy Yi Ou at Hong Kong Polytechnic University and her colleagues at three Business, Finance and Management Schools across China, added another complication. A study of CEOs and senior managers found that narcissism and humility, apparently contradictory characteristics, could coexist. CEOs who combined the two were more likely to display socialised charisma and cultivate innovative cultures and innovative performance.

That suggests the most effective version of the supposedly “dark” CEO may not be the person who abandons humility altogether, but someone capable of combining an extraordinary belief in their own ability with enough self-awareness to recognise their limitations.

Theil’s public persona seemingly rejects this, raising questions over what happens when a leader does away with humility altogether.

He has spent much of his career cultivating a public persona that seems almost designed to reject the conventions of the modern corporate leader. While CEOs have increasingly been encouraged to be authentic, approachable and carefully managed, Thiel has made a virtue of being difficult to categorise, often stereotypically Bond-villain-esque.

His reputation has even spawned tongue-in-cheek online conspiracy theories portraying him as a reptilian hiding in human skin, or a lizard person masquerading as a Silicon Valley billionaire. Though hardly serious allegations, they capture how far his public image has strayed from that of the conventional corporate leader.

His ideas are deliberately provocative, as seen in his 2014 Stanford lecture titled “Competition is for Losers”, which presented an argument that entrepreneurs should seek to create something distinctive rather than compete in crowded markets. He argued that monopolies built on genuine innovation are preferable to competition, a controversial stance that critics say risks legitimising market dominance and the concentration of economic power.

Then there are the more recent lectures…

As previously mentioned, in 2025, Thiel delivered a four-part private lecture series in San Francisco on the Antichrist. Recordings subsequently obtained by The Guardian revealed a sprawling argument about technology, artificial intelligence, regulation, Christianity and the future of society. Thiel argued that attempts to constrain technological development could be more dangerous than the technologies themselves, and linked some advocates of technological regulation to his conception of the Antichrist.

This is not the conventional language of corporate leadership. It is closer to the language of a Bond villain like Elliot Carver, perhaps that is precisely the point.

Thiel does not appear particularly interested in constructing the kind of universally agreeable public persona that has become standard among corporate leaders. He does not need everyone to like him. His ideas are designed to divide, provoke and attract attention.

The Antichrist lectures even contained a self-aware acknowledgement of the value of provocation. Thiel noted that keeping the lectures off the record was “a pretty good marketing shtick” if the intention was to make people hear about them.

That raises a different question from whether Thiel is right about evil.

When the villain gets results

Why deliberately sound like the villain?

One answer may be that modern leadership increasingly rewards differentiation rather than universal approval. A CEO does not need to appeal to everyone. They instead need to convince investors, employees, customers…Presidents… or followers that they possess a distinctive worldview and the confidence to pursue it.

Research by the University of Innsbruck’s Verena Wieser and her colleagues in 2021 found that charismatic leaders can build authority by promoting polarising worldviews, with both supporters and critics contributing to their public profile.

There is an important distinction between being controversial accidentally and being controversial strategically. The former damages reputation. The latter can become reputation.

For Thiel, the provocative persona is arguably inseparable from the ideas he is selling. A conventional CEO arguing for radical technological expansion might sound like another corporate executive making another corporate argument. Thiel talking about the Antichrist, technological stagnation, and the failure of democracy to coexist with freedom is harder to ignore.

That does not make the argument correct. Nor does it make the persona admirable. But it may make it effective.

And that brings us back to his definition of evil.

Thiel’s argument rests on a provocative separation between morality and functionality. Business, after all, is unusually comfortable with this distinction. We routinely celebrate leaders for being ruthless, disruptive, uncompromising or obsessed with winning when those characteristics produce results. We describe them as visionary when they succeed and arrogant when they fail. Much like Steve Jobs, for example, who was celebrated as a visionary who transformed Apple and the consumer-tech industry, despite a leadership style that colleagues described as abrasive and demanding.

The language changes depending on the outcome.

An entrepreneur who refuses to listen to conventional wisdom can be a visionary; the same entrepreneur can become delusional. An executive who makes aggressive decisions can be decisive; they can also be reckless. A CEO with enormous confidence can inspire employees around a radical vision; they can also ignore the evidence that the vision is failing.

Perhaps the real lesson from the research is therefore not that Thiel is right and that evil is competence. It is that competence can sometimes wear an unpleasant face.

The danger is mistaking conviction for competence. The research from the Mannheim Business School into CEO overconfidence shows that it could help a successor turn around a failing business but worsen an incumbent’s decline. The meta-analysis of CEO narcissism similarly illustrates how gains linked to innovation could be offset by harmful strategic decisions. Meanwhile, the research in The Leadership Quarterly suggests that narcissism combined with humility can support the charisma and innovative culture associated with stronger innovation outcomes.

For boards, the research from the University of Innsbruck highlights the importance of looking beyond a leader’s confidence and charisma to how they make decisions. Do they change course when evidence contradicts them? Can they acknowledge mistakes? Are their bold strategies delivering results without exposing the business to unnecessary risks? Self-belief can be an asset, but it must be balanced with self-awareness and accountability.

So perhaps the question for boards is not whether their next CEO is too nice; it is whether they know when the Bond villain has stopped being effective.

Thiel’s distinction between good, evil and bad may be deliberately provocative, but it relays an important feature of leadership. Businesses do not always reward the nicest person in the room. They often reward the person who appears most certain, most ambitious and least constrained by convention.

That can be useful. It can also be dangerous. A company can survive a Bond-villain boss, even one rumoured to be a lizard in human skin. It is far less likely to survive a boardroom that never tells him he is wrong.

Adam Kelly-Moore

Adam holds an LLB and an MA in Broadcast Journalism from Cardiff University. He writes about business, higher education and current affairs, drawing on academic research to explore the ideas and trends behind everything from sport and television to pop culture and the wider world.

About BlueSky Thinking

Business school thinking rarely escapes the campus. BlueSky Thinking changes that. We explore the research, ideas and expertise of the world’s leading faculty, management thinkers and practitioners – enabling their expertise to meet real-world ambition, alongside the rankings, study options and career insight that help ambitious applicants make smarter decisions.

Interested in this topic? You might also like this…

Exit mobile version