Would Losing Titles Hurt Manchester City More Than Deducting Points Or Any Fines?

English football’s long wait appears to be over. Reports emerged on Friday that Manchester City had been found guilty on all but one of the 115 charges. Most concern inaccurate financial reporting over nine seasons, and 35 relate to failing to cooperate with the league’s investigation. The Premier League has not officially published the ruling, no sanction has been set, and City are reportedly planning to appeal.
City dispute the process as well as the outcome. The club has denied wrongdoing throughout, and in 2020 it overturned UEFA’s two-year Champions League ban at the Court of Arbitration for Sport.
The charges cover 2009 to 2018, when City won the Premier League in 2012, 2014 and 2018, with Manchester United finishing second twice and Liverpool runners-up in 2014. Those rivals have been preparing for this moment. Arsenal, Liverpool, United and Tottenham lodged legal notices in November 2024 to protect potential compensation claims from the six-year limitation period, and several clubs have now taken legal advice, although any action has to wait until City’s appeals are exhausted.
If the verdict survives appeal, the rivals’ claims become the next chapter. History, in football and in business, suggests that compensation arrives late, it’s smaller than the loss, it’s fiercely contested, and it never restores the position that was lost. Titles are the exception, and that’s why the question of whether they’re stripped may matter more than any damages claim.
The penalty that would hurt most
The charges cover three of City’s league titles. If they were stripped and handed to the runners-up, Manchester United would gain 2012 and 2018, Liverpool would gain 2014, and the all-time table would look very different.
Today Manchester United and Liverpool share the record on 20 titles each, with Arsenal on 14 after winning last season, and City on 10. After a reallocation, United would move back into the outright lead on 22, Liverpool would have 21, and City would drop to 7, behind Everton that has won 9, and just above Sunderland on 6.
A fine, however large, is a cost that City’s Abu Dhabi owners can absorb. Titles are what the investment was meant to buy, and they’re the one form of redress that changes a rival’s position in the record books as well as its bank balance. For United and Liverpool, whose rivalry is measured in league titles, that could matter more than any compensation cheque.
Italian football shows how long that kind of penalty lingers. In the Calciopoli scandal of 2006, Juventus were stripped of the 2004-05 title, which went unawarded, and the 2005-06 title, which was handed to Inter. Twenty years on, official records credit Juventus with 36 Serie A titles while the club still claims 38, and it has displayed the stripped titles in its stadium. Juventus also pursued damages of up to €551 million from Inter and the Italian federation, and every appeal failed.
City won the 2012 title on goal difference with the last kick of the season, so United’s claim to that one is close. In 2018 City finished with 100 points, 19 clear of United, which makes a retrospective title harder to celebrate. And Steven Gerrard, who never won the league, would finally have a winner’s medal 12 years after the season it was lost.
Football’s price list
The freshest precedent is barely three months old. In June, Everton were ordered to pay Burnley £26 million in damages plus £9.1 million in interest, the first time an English club had successfully sued a rival over the sporting consequences of a financial breach. Burnley had reportedly sought £51.7 million. Everton have appealed and called the ruling a dangerous and unworkable precedent.
The earlier case followed the same pattern. In 2007, West Ham avoided relegation thanks to Carlos Tevez, whose signing broke third-party ownership rules, and Sheffield United went down on the final day. An arbitration panel ruled for Sheffield United in September 2008, and the clubs settled in 2009 for a reported £20 million paid over five years, against an original claim of £45 million.
Both cases took years, both paid out well under half the original claim, and neither returned a club to where it should have been. And both involved a single season. City’s case covers nine.
Deducting enough points would put the title out of reach, and a place in the Champions League. There is also the possibility of being sent down to a lower division, with the pressure that would place on finances without the lucrative Premiership broadcasting deal, and the challenge of keeping their top talent.
A lesson from business with AMD v Intel
The business world’s best-known version of this story is the chip war between Intel and AMD. New York’s Attorney General alleged that Dell received around $300 million a quarter from Intel over five years to keep AMD processors out of its computers. AMD sued, and in November 2009 Intel paid $1.25 billion to settle.
By then AMD’s best chance had passed. At the time of the settlement Intel held 82 percent of the processor market and AMD 18 percent. The cheque compensated AMD for part of what it lost. It did nothing to restore the years when AMD had the stronger product and couldn’t get it into the machines customers were buying.
The case also shows how uncertain these findings can be. Intel’s settlement came with no admission of wrongdoing, and Europe’s top court later upheld the annulment of a €1.06 billion EU fine, ruling that the Commission had not proved Intel’s rebates harmed competition. City’s rivals will note that a guilty verdict is only as strong as its survival on appeal.
How do you put a value on rule breaking?
The hardest part for any claimant is showing what the rule-breaking actually cost them. Kieran Maguire of the University of Liverpool Management School has said the core question is whether owner money was presented as sponsorship, which in his view would amount to fraud.
Research on accounting fraud explains why that kind of misreporting damages competitors. Gil Sadka, then at Columbia Business School, studied WorldCom and showed that a firm whose accounts make it look efficient has to act the part by taking market share or cutting prices. Its rivals then face lower prices, lower output and lower profits. Economist J. Gregory Sidak argued that WorldCom’s rivals believed its inflated growth figures, and that the fraud may have destroyed billions of dollars of shareholder value elsewhere in the industry.
Football’s financial rules work the same way, because declared revenue sets how much a club can spend. If City’s reported income was inflated, rivals set transfer budgets and wage structures against a competitor spending money they couldn’t match within the rules. Turning that into a number for a tribunal is another matter. It means proving which players City couldn’t otherwise have signed, which matches those players decided, and which titles changed hands as a result. Everton are already arguing in Burnley’s case that the causal chain doesn’t hold.
Maguire has suggested Liverpool’s owners may simply treat the legal bill as the cost of doing business. That’s a realistic view of a claim that could take years to resolve.
Why prevention beats redress
Even a clear win can be modest. In January 1993 British Airways apologised in the High Court over its “dirty tricks” campaign against Virgin Atlantic and paid £500,000 to Richard Branson and £110,000 to the airline, plus legal costs estimated at £2 million to £3 million. The campaign had included BA staff posing as Virgin employees to persuade Virgin passengers to switch flights. The damages barely registered for either company. Virgin’s real gain was a public record of what its bigger rival had done, and the departure of BA’s chairman Lord King the same year.
If redress is this weak, prevention matters more, and research shows where the risk is highest. Gavin Kilduff at NYU Stern, working with Adam Galinsky of Columbia, Edoardo Gallo of Cambridge and James Reade of Reading, found rivalry was linked to more deception, unsporting conduct and misreporting of performance. Matches between rivals in Serie A produced more yellow and red card offences, and Ohio State students were four times as likely to lie to Michigan students as to students from non-rival universities.
The researchers explain that rivalry raises the stakes by tying self-worth and status to the result. For boards, that points compliance attention toward the competitive battles that feel most personal, since the courts will do little to repair the damage afterwards.
The fans with no claim
Rival clubs have lawyers and limitation notices. City’s supporters have neither, and they had no part in the accounts or the sponsorship contracts.
The BBC spoke to several of them on Friday. David Mooney of the Blue Moon podcast described a decade of success and brilliant football now shadowed by the sense that others see it as illegitimate. His conclusion was generous and sharp at once: if City are guilty, “the City fans are just as much the victims in this as everybody else”.
Many remember a very different club. City won promotion through the play-offs in 1998-99 after a season facing York City, Oldham Athletic and Chesterfield. Season ticket holder John said nobody could take away what he experienced in Istanbul at the 2023 Champions League final. Another supporter, David Wilson, said fans mainly want an explanation of why, if the club is guilty, the process took so long.
Research from Bournemouth University suggests those memories will hold. Ian Jones, Andrew Adams and Joanne Mayoh studied Newcastle supporters after the Saudi-backed takeover and found fans used “motivated ignorance” alongside other strategies to protect their identification with the club when it came under threat.
Whatever the appeal decides, the rivals will eventually get a hearing and possibly a cheque, late, smaller than they hoped and fought over line by line. The fans who sang through those nine seasons keep those memories, that may now come with an asterisk.
Interested in this topic? You might also like…
