Skip to content

Men Argued About The New Jaguar For Two Years, But Women May Decide Whether It Survives

At a trendy New York venue Jaguar has finally showed the world a car. It has been a long wait. In November 2024 Jaguar stopped selling new cars in the UK and launched its reinvention with a film that featured no cars at all.

Elon Musk asked whether Jaguar still sold cars. Nigel Farage predicted it would go bust. For two years Jaguar has been the most argued-over brand in marketing.

Among the people who analyse brands for a living, two voices have carried the most weight. Mark Ritson, the marketing professor turned columnist, has been Jaguar’s most persistent critic. Rory Sutherland, vice chairman of Ogilvy, has been its most prominent defender. 

Both have now had their say on the finished product. The Type 01 is a four-door electric grand tourer with more than 1,000 horsepower, no rear window and a starting price of £130,000. Orders open early in 2027.

Strip away the theory and our question is a simple one. Would Sutherland, who has owned six Jaguars, buy a seventh? And would Ritson, who as far as we know has never owned one, buy his first?

Mark Ritson gives the new Jaguar 45 out of 70

Ritson arrived at the launch with seven questions and left with a score. After sitting down with Jaguar managing director Rawdon Glover, he gave the reset 45 out of 70 in The Drum. A pass, and not much more.

His objections have been consistent since 2024. Jaguar said at the time that it expected to keep only 10 to 15% of its existing buyers. Ritson’s view is that those owners are the brand’s most loyal fans and the likeliest people anywhere to buy an electric Jaguar, if only someone asked them. Switching from petrol to battery, in his eyes, doesn’t change what the badge means.

He also thinks Jaguar threw away too much of what made it recognisable. That idea comes from the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute at the University of South Australia, where Jenni Romaniuk has spent years studying distinctive brand assets: the colours, shapes and symbols that let people spot a brand without reading its name. Jaguar, Ritson argued, went into 2024 with one of the richest sets of those assets in the car industry, and then hid them.

The car itself did more to win him round than any of the marketing. Before the launch he wrote that a great Type 01 mattered about 9,000 times more to Jaguar’s future than a poor video. In New York he found Jaguar still oddly shy about its own heritage. It was the moment, he said, to be proudly British, and Jaguar went for globally tasteful instead.

So would he buy one? Nothing in his verdict suggests he is reaching for his chequebook. His real test is three years away: whether people who never considered a Jaguar start to, and whether there are enough of them to keep the company going.

Rory Sutherland’s case for a seventh Jaguar

Sutherland comes to Jaguar as a customer first. He has owned six. When the 2024 campaign landed, he argued that Jaguar needed a bold break to save a fading brand, and that many of its loudest critics had never owned a Jaguar and never would.

That cuts both ways. By Sutherland’s test, Ritson’s critique counts for less than his own. Ritson could reply that people who have never bought a Jaguar are exactly the ones the company now needs.

Sutherland’s school is behavioural. People buy on feeling, context and status, and a choice that looks odd on a spreadsheet can make sense in the buyer’s head. He likes to point out that Rolls-Royce and Maserati started selling at yacht and private jet shows, because after a morning looking at Learjets a £300,000 car feels like an impulse buy. 

Applied to Jaguar, the question is less whether £130,000 is good value next to a Porsche Taycan and more where buyers are standing when they first see the price. A launch in Manhattan, with screens in Times Square, fits that thinking better than a motor show stand.

Sutherland has also been in the car. He rode in a prototype on Jaguar’s test track with Glover and the podcaster Jon Evans for an episode of Uncensored CMO, which billed the car as a design and engineering miracle and included a segment on why it is a bargain at £130,000.

Would he buy a seventh? Everything he has said points to yes. The catch is that he is exactly the buyer Jaguar planned to lose: a long-standing British owner. If Sutherland signs up, it proves the old loyalists can follow the brand. It tells us nothing about whether anyone new will.

Why Women Car Buyers Are Missing From The Jaguar Debate

Count the people who have shaped this story: Ritson, Sutherland, Glover, Evans, Musk, Farage. Almost every loud voice in the Jaguar debate has been a man, arguing about a brand that says it wants a different kind of customer.

Akshara Chandhok, a strategy consultant writing in The Intercooler in January 2025, saw this early. The stereotype of the Jaguar driver is an older, conservative, upper-middle-class man, and she argued that group had not made up most of Jaguar’s buyers for some time. Her bigger point was that no carmaker was going after wealthy women with cars that were elegant and expressive. The market offered them small, cute hatchbacks or big, practical SUVs. That gap, she suggested, was Jaguar’s opening.

The record backs her up. The Jaguar XF was the first Women’s World Car of the Year in 2010, and the F-Pace won the same award in 2016. Chandhok’s own mother swapped her last minivan for an S-Type when she turned 50 and has bought Jaguars ever since. Yet Jaguar’s own marketing team once admitted that only 1 in 10 of its cars was sold to a woman, at a time when women bought more than 40% of new cars and influenced 85% of buying decisions.

Not every woman writing about the Type 01 is sold. In The Guardian, Zoe Williams said it was too big for a UK parking space and looked more like a tank than a car.

Ritson’s argument is about keeping the buyers Jaguar already has. Sutherland’s is about the psychology that gets people to buy. What about the buyer Chandhok describes, who may never have set foot in a Jaguar showroom because nobody ever asked her to?

Florence Pugh And The New Jaguar Customer

Jaguar may already have given its answer through its choice of ambassador. In New York it named Florence Pugh, the Oscar-nominated British actor, as the first ambassador of its new era. She stood on stage with Glover while English singer-songwriter Sienna Spiro performed.

It is a telling pick. Pugh is British, which goes some way to meeting Ritson’s complaint about a launch that played down its roots. She is also the kind of figure followed by the younger, richer and largely American audience that Euronews reported Jaguar is chasing. And she looks a good deal more like the customer Chandhok described than the one Jaguar was known for.

Celebrity ambassadors don’t sell £130,000 cars on their own, and Jaguar knows it. What the choice does show is who the company pictures in the driver’s seat.

Rory Sutherland has a closer test at home. His wife, Sophie, is a priest. It is fair to guess that the marketers profiling a younger, richer, largely American buyer did not have a parish priest in mind. Yet if women influence 85% of car-buying decisions, her view of a £130,000 electric GT may count for as much as his. So before he orders a seventh Jaguar, he might ask Sophie if she would want to be seen getting out of one.

Interested in this topic? You might also like…

1 Comment »

Leave a Reply