Skip to content

Could Your Board Name The Next CEO Tomorrow? Lessons From Nvidia And Apple

Which of the Magnificent Seven of Big Tech would pass the Tomorrow Test today?

A founder who runs everything can build a $5 trillion company. New business school research shows what that buys, when the bill arrives, and which of today’s tech giants are ready to lose their leader.

On 1 September, John Ternus took over from Tim Cook as Apple’s chief executive. The handover had been announced in April, Cook stayed on as executive chairman, and investors hardly blinked. On 14 October Apple closed above $5 trillion for the first time, and on 13 November it set another record.

Nvidia has gone the other way. On 6 October it was worth nearly $5.8 trillion. Then came the revelations about Jensen Huang’s private life, his resignation on 12 November, and the appointment of finance chief Colette Kress as interim CEO with no permanent successor named. On Friday 20 November the shares fell another 14%, on top of reports of an SEC accounting investigation, and Nvidia closed the week worth about $3 trillion. That is nearly half its October value, and fourth place among US companies behind Apple, Microsoft and Alphabet.

Succession explains only part of the gap. Apple has been rewarded this year for spending far less on AI infrastructure than its rivals. Nvidia was sliding before the scandal broke, and the reported SEC investigation is a separate problem. The two companies do give a clean answer to one question, which I’ll call the Tomorrow Test: if the CEO left tomorrow, could the board name a successor, and would investors believe in that person? Apple could. Nvidia couldn’t.

What founder-CEOs give a company?

Joon Mahn Lee of Korea University, Jongsoo Kim of Hong Kong Baptist University and Joonhyung Bae of UNIST in South Korea studied US public companies whose CEO died suddenly between 1979 and 2002. When a founder was replaced by a professional CEO, the company’s citation-weighted patent count fell by 43.8%, even after allowing for R&D spending. Huang co-founded Nvidia in 1993, pushed it into general-purpose computing with CUDA years before there was a clear market, and made it the first company worth $5 trillion. He ran it with no chief operating officer and around 60 senior executives reporting directly to him.

Huang also had a considered case against succession planning. On the Lex Fridman podcast earlier this year he said he didn’t believe in it, and that the priority was to pass on knowledge, skills and experience as often as possible. He once said his 60 direct reports could take over as CEO because they knew everything.

Recent research gives him some cover. Eric Lee of Texas A&M’s Mays Business School and Donald Hambrick of Penn State’s Smeal College of Business, writing in Organization Science in 2025, describe succession planning as a risky investment. It takes up the time of the CEO and the board, can create tension between them, and sets senior executives against each other. Groomed heirs sometimes leave before they get the job. Lee and Hambrick argue that a board that skips formal planning may have weighed the costs sensibly. Huang reportedly made the same point, telling colleagues that a succession race would be divisive.

When an indispensable CEO becomes a liability

Nvidia’s first results under Kress beat forecasts, with record quarterly revenue of $115.8 billion. The market marked the shares down anyway. Investors call this key-person risk: the chance that a company’s value depends on someone who can’t be replaced.

Bradley Hendricks and Christopher Bingham of UNC Kenan-Flagler and Travis Howell, now at Arizona State University’s W.P. Carey School of Business, studied about 2,000 listed companies. Founder-led firms were worth about 10% more at IPO, but the advantage shrank to zero roughly 3 years after listing, and longer-serving founder-CEOs went on to reduce firm value on average. Huang, 27 years after Nvidia’s IPO, is a rare exception, in the same small group as Jeff Bezos. Exceptions are the hardest people to replace.

The gap a CEO leaves has also grown. Timothy Quigley of the University of Georgia’s Terry College of Business and Hambrick estimate that about 25% of the variation in company performance can now be traced to the CEO, against 6% to 8% in the 1950s and 1960s. Morten Bennedsen of INSEAD and the University of Copenhagen, with Francisco Pérez-González, now at ITAM in Mexico City and previously at Stanford, and Daniel Wolfenzon of Columbia Business School, found that when a CEO spends around 10 days in hospital, operating profitability falls by about 4%. The effect was strongest where power was concentrated at the top.

That is the weakness in Huang’s model. Sharing knowledge with 60 people spreads understanding, but all 60 still report to one person. When he goes, nobody has the authority, the customer relationships or the board’s confidence to take over the next morning. Fortune noted that none of Nvidia’s 7 other directors had run a Fortune 500 company, and four had been on the board for 13 years or more.

Does CEO succession planning pay off?

Yan Anthea Zhang of Rice University’s Jones Graduate School of Business and Nandini Rajagopalan of USC’s Marshall School of Business compared 204 CEO successions. Companies that groomed an heir and handed over in a planned “relay” performed better afterwards than those that picked an insider at the last minute or hired from outside. They titled the paper “When the known devil is better than an unknown god.”

Korn Ferry published fresh numbers this week from successions at more than 3,600 large and mid-sized listed companies in 2025. About 1 in 4 was unprepared. Prepared boards named a successor within an average of 15 days of the departure being announced; unprepared boards took 98. Within 3 years, 57% of the CEOs appointed in unprepared successions had already gone, against 27% in prepared ones. A Wharton Executive Education survey released on 10 November found that 86% of business leaders call succession planning critical, but only 48% think their organisation is very prepared.

How Apple planned the handover from Tim Cook to John Ternus

Apple once had its own indispensable founder. Steve Jobs designed products, ran the keynotes and shaped the culture in his own image. Apple still built a successor. Cook ran the company day to day during Jobs’s medical leaves in 2004, 2009 and 2011, so when Jobs stepped down six weeks before his death, the board already knew what Cook could do.

Cook then ran the planned version. In November 2023 he told Dua Lipa on her podcast that Apple had “very detailed succession plans”. Jeff Williams retired as chief operating officer in late 2025, leaving Ternus as the clear frontrunner. The board approved him unanimously, announced the change more than 4 months ahead, and kept Cook on as executive chairman. Jobs had the founder’s boldness, and the board still had a name ready.

Who would pass the Tomorrow Test today?

Here’s how the most valuable US tech companies, plus OpenAI and Berkshire Hathaway, look on public information.

CompanyCEOGradeWhy
AppleJohn Ternus (since Sept 2026)ReadyPlanned relay, years in the making, with Cook as executive chairman
Berkshire HathawayGreg Abel (since Jan 2026)ReadyNamed as Buffett’s successor in 2021 and ran the non-insurance businesses for years first
MicrosoftSatya Nadella (since 2014)Partly readyNo named heir, but Judson Althoff has run the commercial business as its CEO since October 2025
AmazonAndy Jassy (since 2021)Partly readyHas done a planned founder handover once; no visible heir today
AlphabetSundar Pichai (since 2015)Partly readySpeculation about DeepMind’s Demis Hassabis, but no named successor
BroadcomHock Tan (since 2006)Partly readyCommitted to stay “through 2030, at least”; no named successor
MetaMark Zuckerberg (founder)At riskFounder with voting control; the FT reports only informal talk of Alexandr Wang as a future successor
TeslaElon MuskAt riskBoard says it has contingency plans and Musk’s pay deal requires a succession framework, but much of the value rests on Musk
OpenAISam Altman (co-founder)At riskIts presumed number two, Fidji Simo, stepped back in July; some shareholders have floated Bret Taylor
NvidiaColette Kress (interim)FailedTook the test for real on 12 November

The pattern is clear. The companies that pass have all handed over at least once before, and they did it while the outgoing leader was still around to help. The companies at risk are run by founders or near-founders whose personal reputations carry a large share of the valuation.

What Nvidia’s board should do next

Shivaram Rajgopal of Columbia Business School has suggested pairing Kress with a technology leader and holding on to key engineers, many of whom are wealthy enough to leave. Kress has already brought forward pay reviews and equity awards. Internal names in the frame include Ian Buck, whose work helped create CUDA, and sales chief Jay Puri. On Korn Ferry’s numbers, every week the board waits makes the eventual handover harder.

Lee and Hambrick are right that succession planning has costs. Nvidia has now shown what skipping it costs, and some of the $2.7 trillion it has lost since October is the price. Weeks before he resigned, Huang said he was “really hoping that the next CEO of the company’s already at the company”.

He may well be right. The board just never wrote the name down.

Interested in this topic? You might also like…

Leave a Reply