Why Researchers May Need To Rethink Collectivism

By, Lucy Whytock
There’s an African philosophy called ubuntu: the idea that a person’s sense of self is shaped by their relationships with others.
In an interview with the Consortium of Humanities, Centers and Institutes, Professor James Ogunde describes the concept which, with roots in Bantu communities, has a “history as old as humanity itself”. Rather than seeing the individual as separate from the community, he shares, ubuntu starts from the idea that who we are is connected to the people around us. It is a powerful example of how cultures can place relationships and obligations central to social life
For decades, the word “collectivism” has been used to describe such cultures, that place greater emphasis on the group than the individual, and use this to forge a shared identity or purpose. It’s a concept that has been studied extensively in academia, exploring the power such movements hold.
But what if researchers have measured this idea insufficiently?
In a new study led by Thomas Talhelm, Robert Cialdini Endowed Professor of Social Influence at Arizona State University, it is suggested that this broad definition may have blurred two different ideas: general warmth towards other people, and concrete duties towards family and close relationships.
Those, the researchers state, are not the same, and the distinction matters as understanding collectivism is important not only in academia but in real life too, shaping our workplaces, our politics our history and even our economies.
Confusing the two, they continue, could help explain why previous research has produced inconsistent results into the merits of collectivism as a whole.
Talhelm’s research poses a straightforward question: before describing a culture, workplace or institutions as collectivist, what kind of collectivism do we actually mean?
What does collectivism actually measure?
For years, researchers have typically used the term collectivism to describe how far different cultures emphasise family duty and group identity over individual independence. Yet traditional surveys have sometimes produced puzzling results. A meta-analysis of 76 survey studies, for example, found no reliable differences in collectivism between East Asian and Western cultures, despite the long-standing assumption that East Asian cultures are inherently far more collectivistic.
Talhelm’s research points to a possible explanation: the word “collectivism” has been used to cover two related but distinctly different ideas.
One is what the researchers describe as the “warm fuzzy” collectivism. A general positivity towards other people, reflected in sociability, friendliness and enjoyment of company. An example of this would be having thoughts like, ‘to me, pleasure is spending time with others.’
The other is more specific and more demanding. It concerns duties within close relationships, including what people believe they owe to parents, children, relatives and others closest to them that go on to shape how they function. For example, agreeing that ‘we should keep our aging parents with us at home.’
There can be an overlap between the two, but they cannot be interchangeable, Talhelm explains. One person may enjoy being around others without feeling strong family obligations; another may feel deep responsibility to relatives without being especially sociable.
This was the case with a 1995 study which refined concepts of individualism and collectivism but also included findings that failed to capture the researchers’ expected differences between East Asian and Western societies.
Talhelm’s research points to a possible explanation: the word collectivism has been made to cover two related but differently distinct ideas.
This distinction is where Talhelm’s new concept of “responsibilism” comes in.
From collectivism to responsibilism
Rather than measuring about general orientation towards groups, responsibilism focuses on duties, roles and responsibilities in close relationships, while allowing for weaker obligation towards distant people.

The researchers translated the scale into 45 languages and gave it to 12,247 people across 100 different cultures, representing around 90% of the world’s population. This allowed the researchers to compare how people understood responsibilities towards different kinds of relationships across a much broader range of cultures than many earlier studies.
The results showed clear regional differences. Africa and South Asia recorded the highest levels of responsibilism, followed by East Asia, Southeast Asia and Central Asia. North America, Europe and Australia recorded the lowest.
Importantly, responsibilism showed little overlap with eight of the most widely cited collectivism scales. This suggests that the new concept is capturing something different from the broad measures researchers have traditionally relied on.
The researchers then tested whether the new measure corresponded with real-world indicators of close relationships. Responsibilism was associated with behaviours such as whether people were more likely to donate blood to family members or strangers, whether they lived alone, and whether they believed people should lie for friends in court. Across these indicators, it was a stronger predictor than older collectivism measures.
Taken together, the findings challenge the assumption that collectivism can be captured through one broad measure. The research instead points to the need for sharper distinctions between sociability, group identity and obligation to close relationships.
Collectivism in the workplace
Collectivism does not always have to look warm and fuzzy. Collective power can also emerge when people come together to support others facing the same problem, to push for change.
Recent strike action in New York, for example, saw more than 15,000 nurses from three separate hospital trusts walk out in support of one another during disputes over pay and working conditions. Not every nurse, or indeed every trust, faced the same conditions but despite this collectively supported colleagues whose negotiations had broken down.
Both examples demonstrate the power of people acting collectively, but they also raise a question at the heart of Talhelm’s research: is collective action necessarily driven by a general warmth towards the group, or by a specific sense of responsibility towards those within it?
The idea is not entirely new. Geert Hofstede, whose work became hugely influential in the study of cultural difference, described collectivism in terms of people knowing their “place” in the wider social world and duties attached to their in-groups. His work helped establish individualism-collectivism as a major framework for comparing cultures. Talhelm’s research builds on this tradition while arguing that researchers need to be more precise about what they are measuring.
That precision matters beyond psychology. In workplaces, terms such as collaboration, teamwork and shared culture are often used as though they mean the same thing. Talhelm’s distinction suggests, they may not.
One employee may value teamwork because they enjoy collaborating with others. Another may feel a particular obligation to a close group of colleagues, a department or a senior figure. From the outside, both may look “collectivist”, but the motivations underneath are very different.
Research from the University of South Florida, University of Waterloo (Canada) and Smarter Workforce Institute supports the idea that these cultural differences have practical implications. The study found that societal individualism-collectivism influenced how workplace decision-making autonomy and performance feedback, related to employee strain. The findings suggest that the effectiveness of workplace practices can vary depending on the wider cultural context.
There is further research from University of Seville and University of Beira Interior, which highlights a potential tension within collectivism itself. The study examines how collectivism can impair team performance when maintaining relationships with particular group members conflicts with achieving the group’s wider goals. This reinforces an important distinction: prioritising close relationships is not always the same as prioritising the collective as a whole.
These differences difference matters because group-oriented values can support cooperation, loyalty and mutual support. They can also shape how people respond to disagreement, conflict and pressure from those closest to the group.
This is where Talheim’s term, ‘responsibilism’ becomes useful. Rather than treating collectivism as a general orientation towards the group, it focuses attention on the responsibilities people feels towards those with whom they share the closest relationship t
Therefore, it may give researchers a more accurate way of describing why people behave in group-orientated ways rather than assuming all social butterflies have the same underlying values.
Getting collectivism right
What does this mean for academia? If the concept of collectivism is imprecise, the conclusions built on it may be imprecise too.
Talhelm’s study suggests that researchers should avoid treating collectivism as a fixed characteristic of a country or population. Instead, they need to specify exactly what they are examining. Is the focus on sociability, group identity, family obligation or responsibility towards close relationships? Each of those tells a different story.
The same matters for universities and organisations working across cultures. Without it, a broad label can slide too easily from being an explanation into becoming a stereotype.
The contribution of responsibilism helps to protect against this, by separating the softer idea of people banding together from the actionable responsibility people feel towards those around them. This is knowledge that organisations – whether social or practical can use to ensure the protections of people and the continuation of purpose.
Better definitions lead to better research. They can also help managers, universities and institutions avoid making easy assumptions about how people from different societies think, collaborate or handle obligation.
It also brings the discussion back to the relationships at the heart of concepts such as ubuntu. Rather than asking whether a culture is simply collectivist or individualist, the question may be: collectivist in what way, and towards whom? Culture is not just a choice between the individual and the group. It is also about which relationships create responsibility, and what people believe they owe to others.
Lucy Whytock
Lucy Whytock writes at the intersection of business, education, and trending culture, transforming big ideas into stories everyone can relate to.
About BlueSky Thinking
Business school thinking rarely escapes the campus. BlueSky Thinking changes that. We explore the research, ideas and expertise of the world’s leading faculty, management thinkers and practitioners – enabling their expertise to meet real-world ambition, alongside the rankings, study options and career insight that help ambitious applicants make smarter decisions.
Interested in this topic? You might also like this…
